Tuesday, September 15, 2009

The Fight Over Healthcare Reform

After having a rather spirited debate with one of my college friends about healthcare reform, it got me thinking, why is this issue getting so many people across the spectrum so riled up? The answer is simple. This is the first time the U.S. government is actually close to passing legislation that will transform the current healthcare system in this country.

My friend is against the public option and brought up some good points especially with regards to cost. There are cost-cutting measures in place in the current bill, but she is right we really can't be sure how much these reforms will cost in the long run. I’ll tell you what though: I am much more willing to give up a bigger share of my paycheck to make sure my fellow Americans get healthcare than I am to see that money go to the senseless war in Iraq.

The public option is a proposed health insurance plan that would offered by the U.S. government.

Other thoughts...

1) Some people have suggested that instead of creating a public option for all Americans, we should start by reforming already existing government-run healthcare programs like Medicare and Medicaid. To start by doing a "trial run" for the public option with Medicare and Medicaid will add just a drop in the healthcare reform bucket. Making reforms in these two programs are necessary but their patient eligibility makes their impact limited. The millions of Americans who have absolutely no coverage are not eligible for either program unless their circumstances change drastically (i.e. they turn 65 or become destitute). These are people who are bankrupted by medical bills and who use emergency rooms as their primary care. The question to ask is: Can currently uninsured Americans (especially those who are already sick) afford to wait another 10, 20, 30 years or how ever long it takes to see if this “trial run” works out? That’s another entire generation of uninsured Americans. And who is to say that 10, 20, 30 years from now, the political climate will allow for this kind of wide-scale reform to occur?

Some people don't realize that Medicare is essentially the public option for seniors.

2) Those against the public option say that a free market health system creates the best care, but for whom? Only those who can afford it. Much of the praise for American medicine comes from their breakthroughs with experimental care. However, very few insurance companies cover these kinds of treatments. Unless a patient has money to pay for these procedures out of pocket or is insured by a company that does cover them (usually with astronomical yearly premiums), he/she will not receive experimental treatments. So even with the current system as it exists now, sometimes people who are already insured don’t get the life-saving treatments they need. The plan Obama is trying to pass will allow people to keep their existing plans (so their treatments will not be affected) but more importantly, it will allow for millions of Americans who currently have zero coverage to receive health care.

I never saw the need for covering the uninsured more clearly than during my three years in the classroom. So many of my students and their families still struggle to get even basic treatment. Over half of my students last year were uninsured and many times received their health care at Urgent Care or ER facilities, often times paying hundreds of dollars for health problems that could have been avoided with less expensive preventive medicine.

Waiting for ER care.

Under a public health care plan that will no longer be an issue. Giving people preventive care will save money down the line too. Many people end up in emergency rooms because they didn’t get preventive care when they needed it and then waited until a health problem became so severe that they had not choice but to go to the ER for an extremely costly visit.

3) The anti-Semitic, right-wing protesters showing up at town hall meetings around the country with derogatory posters threatening violence against the president and depicting him as Adolf Hilter should be condemned. Congressman Barney Frank said it best; these people are from another planet. Further research into these so-called "grassroots" protesters uncover links to groups funded by Republican party operatives who use fear-mongering tactics to obscure the facts of this debate. Valid arguments presented by both sides are being drowned out by these raucous people.

Man who obviously needs a history lesson.

It is easier to compare President Obama to Hitler than it is to actually educate people on the policies entailed in this bill and the arguments for or against it. Even those with the most elementary knowledge of history know that Obama is in no way shape or form a Nazi. The mere comparison is a vitriolic attack on both the president and the survivors of that heinous era.

4) Labor unions should be applauded for being on the side of the public option and for going as far as threatening congressional Democrats with withdrawing their electoral support for them if they do not support new healthcare reforms. That is a huge statement from blue-collar, middle, America (union members) and it shows how badly they want reforms made right now. And that’s coming from a constituency that already has healthcare policies built into their contracts! The support for reform is mainstream and it makes sense why when you learn that the US spends twice as much per capita on healthcare as any other nation and yet we have 46 million uninsured citizens. Who wouldn’t be up in arms about that?

5) The first step in improving healthcare in America is improving the health of Americans. Last year I had several students who were morbidly obese. One of them already had diabetes. These are 11-year-old kids who come from immigrant households where parents often work two or more jobs and aren’t home to prepare nutritious food for their children, or if they are home, often prepare cultural meals (laden with sodium, fats, and carbohydrates) that are less than healthful.

The lack of available nutritious food in these communities is also appalling. In the eastside of LA where I taught, there are no Whole Foods, Trader Joe’s, farmers markets, etc. You are twice as likely to find a fast food joint, buffet restaurant or taco truck on the corner than you are one of those stores.
The food kids are served at school is also abominable. At my former school, students got a coffee cake or donut and chocolate milk for breakfast every day. At lunch they had their choice of a burger, hotdog, pizza or burrito. How does that not make kids fat? It does and overweight kids are more likely to need medical care than normal weight children. The poverty, food, and healthcare are all entangled in a destructive interconnected web.

A typical school lunch in America.

Ultimately, it all comes back to education. Educating parents and children about nutrition and portion sizes. Efforts are being made in California and nationwide to educate parents and kids to eat healthier and I know in time the obesity epidemic will get better, but for now what do we say to kids like my uninsured diabetic student whose parents could barely afford his out-of-pocket medicines? "Tough luck kid; sorry you’re poor, sick and uninsured?" I think that’s a travesty that has been perpetrated for far too long.

I’ve been fortunate enough to have health insurance all my life, but I can sympathize with people who see this as a life or death issue because for some folks it is. The time for reform is now. We’ve never been this close.


Thursday, September 3, 2009

Oh Levi!

Levi during one of his many media appearances.

Levi Johnston just won't shut up. Ever since his almost, future mother-in-law lost the the VP spot in last year's presidential election, Levi has been on a media blitz. Every time this kid opens his mouth we hear more and more about how much a fraud Sarah Palin really is. He even says there are worst things yet to reveal about Palin. I wonder what those could be? Oh please, do tell! Levi has found a way to serve his country and that's by outing Sarah Palin for the phony she really is. God bless him for it.