Saturday, November 8, 2008

Racial Gap at Elite NYC Public Schools

I just read this disturbing piece from the New York Times which described the racial imbalance at the city's top public high schools. Admission to these schools is based solely on a test students take in the eighth grade. Hispanic and black students perform poorly on this test and, in fact, many of them chose to not take the test all together. Even though they make up 72% of the population of the New York City public school district, only about half of them sit for the exam.


From that group, those offered admission to the top specialized high schools like Stuyvesant High School, Bronx High School of Science and Brooklyn Tech, make up on average about 8%-12% of the student population at these schools. Stuyvesant, the most selective of all the schools, has the worst statistics. Out of 3,247 students, only 5% of them are black and Hispanic! Really? Five percent? Remember we are talking about three-fourths of all the kids that go to public school in New York. Even more shocking to me was that Asians make up 72% of the students at Stuyvesant even though they are only 14% of the public school population. How is this happening? Well, I know how, but why? Why is it happening?

To address these glaring racial gaps, New York set up the "Specialized High Schools Institute" a few years back. The institute is aimed at diversifying the schools by preparing students for the exam through a 16-month long course. The black and Hispanic kids who attend the institute do better on the exam. Still, the institute has not helped improve the dismal numbers at Stuyvesant.

Now I don't know anyone personally who has attended Styvusant but the school has always fascinated me. It is on par with all the Phillips, Choates and Deerfields of the world, but there is one difference. It is essentially a prestigous, top private school that charges no tuition because it is funded by taxpayers. I have nothing against elite public schools (God knows we need more of them!) but I do take issue with a public school whose population is in no way reflective the population of its district. It's sad to think how little has changed since Brown v. Board of Education. Schools today are more segregated today than they were in the 1950s. The achievement gap is to blame, of course, but I also think that the policies dictating how students are selected for these schools are to blame too.

Why does it all always come down to a test? Why can't students be selected based on their work ethic and their willingness to attend a "catch up" summer program? Why hasn't New York expanded the "Specialized High Schools Institute" for black and Latino students and required those who attend the institute to take the exam? Why hasn't New York made this test mandatory for all city eighth graders, not just those who have the resources and knowledge to take it?

Why?

No comments: