Monday, December 29, 2008

Another Senator Kennedy?

Recently there has been a lot of talk in the media over Caroline Kennedy's desire to be named Hillary Clinton's replacement in the Senate. New York Governor David Paterson has said he will not appoint someone until Hillary's seat is officially vacant (translation: mid to late January). Some pundits have said Caroline lacks the experience and is only a serious contender for this seat because she is part of America's greatest political family, the Kennedys. Caroline, who for many years avoided the public spotlight that comes with being a Kennedy, is now out in full force campaigning for a seat once held by her Uncle Bobby.

Caroline Kennedy and her father, President John F. Kennedy.


The question is: Is Caroline Kennedy qualified to be a United States Senator from New York? I don't think so. Sure, she has done many good things in her life. She raised three kids, wrote a few books, headed up several charities, worked to improve New York City schools, and led Obama's Vice Presidental selection committee. But, she's never held public office, nor has she ever shown an interest in pursuing a career in politics. Why should she be allowed to leap from the title of "mom/ author/ philanthropist/ political aide" right to "US Senator"? Just because her father was a president? Perhaps, a better question to ask is: Would Caroline Kennedy even be considered for this seat were it not for her last name? I think not.

Having Caroline Kennedy fill Hillary's seat creates many problems. First, it's unfair to New York politicians who have put in their time and served the public for many years--people like the Speaker of the New York City Council Christine Quinn and 11-term Congresswoman Nita Lowey who don't have the benefit of famous ancestors. Second, it's undemocratic to select a woman with no political experience or much knowledge of the state besides Manhattan and its surrounding boroughs to speak for all New Yorkers. If Caroline really wants the seat and the people of New York really want her to fill it, then let her get elected to it.

Christine Quinn is the first woman and the first openly gay Speaker of the NYCC

Third, it's unpatriotic to give in to nepotism. This country, despite its continual hypocrisy, was founded on the ideals of a government of, by and for the people--not of, by and for the family members of powerful families. I know that may sound incredibly naive but even though America has not always held true to that promise, let's at least continue to try.

No comments: